It’s a shame a guy like Tom Renney has to pay for the incompetence of others. But that’s just how things go sometimes. If at first you don’t succeed, simply blame somebody else. If that doesn’t work, fire them. That’s how GMs the world over have been doing business for eons. No reason that Glen Sather’s mantra should be any different. In almost eight years as a general manager of the Rangers, Slats has shown none of the aptitude that made him one of the most successful coaches in NHL history. Far from it, in fact. Pre-lockout moves for the likes of Erik Lindros, Bobby Holik and Pavel Bure crippled the team’s development. The new collective bargaining agreement and salary cap forced him to alter that course, at least temporarily, before he returned to he idiocy of his old ways (2007 signings of Chris Drury, Scott Gomez and Markus Naslund).

This, more than anything else, is what proved to be the team’s undoing this season. Yes, Renney should have shuffled his lines far less and played Petr Prucha far more than he did. That he failed to do either was unfortunate–but it was not the reason for the team’s malaise.

What has happened is this: The inmates are now running the asylum. Gomez and Drury were never leaders of the various championship teams they played for before joining the Rangers. Instead, they were role players. Valuable role players for sure, and maybe not quite expendable parts either, but role players nonetheless. Putting these guys in a position to captain (Drury) and assistant captain (Gomez) this team was just not going to work. The last two seasons Jaromir Jagr and to a lesser extent Sean Avery performed the leadership duties pretty effectively. With both of them gone this season, the Rangers ship quickly lost its rudder–with predictable results.

The fact that the team has managed to keep it together as well as it did (and remains in a playoff spot) is a testament to Renney’s abilities as a coach. Unfortunately, he too struggled with the lack of scoring power, which might explain the constant juggling and re-juggling of lines. Ultimately, this team, built by Sather, is just not very good. Besides the aforementioned leadership void, the team is weak at every single position except goaltender. The defensemen are too slow, the wingers too small, the centers too passive. Until that changes, don’t expect this team to do much better than it has. Sure, there may be a short-term bounce due to the change in leadership. There often is. But it will be short-lived. The team probably needs to be gutted and the responsible parties (Slats) need to be held accountable. Unless and until that happens, we don’t see the Rangers going anywhere.

Posted under Uncategorized

The New York Rangers are in freefall. This much is clear. After yesterday’s embarrassing 5-2 loss to the Philadelphia Flyers, the team has won just once in its last eight games and is in danger of all but disappearing from the Atlantic Division race. Time to point the finger. Actually, first it’s time to play a little game called “I told you so.” Back on Feb. 2, my last appearance in this space, I cautioned that the season appeared to have suffered an unfortunate turn, from which the team might not recover:

“We can go as far as to pinpoint the precise moment when perhaps (though hopefully not) the fortunes shifted dramatically in the Rangers season: The start of the third period in Pittsburgh last Wednesday (Jan. 28).”

As it turns out, that loss in Pittsburgh turned out to be the start of its present slump (the “last eight games” referred to above). I point this out partly mainly largely because I want to demonstrate how brilliant I am and that you absolutely should stick with me here, even if I disappear for weeks at a time (not by choice but due to my various other obligations, including my wretched day job). More importantly, however, this demonstrates just how desperate the Rangers are for a change in momentum if they are to salvage the season. Can the current coaching staff deliver the goods? Tonight should give us an idea, but the signs are not encouraging. Many of the players, chief among them Scott Gomez, appear to have quit on Renney. With Sean Avery not yet available, management simply does not have many other options to provide a spark. If the Rangers lose at St. Louis tonight, the Renney era at Madison Square Garden could be over.

Lost in this equation is the fact that Renney is not the biggest culprit for the team’s current malaise. That honor goes to Glen Sather, who saddled the team with overpriced free agents (Gomez, Chris Drury, Wade Redden). Ironically, Sather will be the guy dropping the ax on Renney’s stint as Rangers head coach. I’m not saying Renney doesn’t deserve some blame (why oh why does he refuse to play Petr Prucha for example?) but the larger problems with this team are a reflection of Sather’s moves as general manager. If anybody needs to go, it’s him. But there’s no justice in this world. Everybody knows that.

Posted under Uncategorized

By “this” I mean the last two games, both very tough road losses that have left the Rangers reeling in fifth place in the Eastern Conference. The Rangers are even on points with the fourth-placed Montreal Canadiens, who have a game in hand and one point ahead of sixth-placed Philadelphia, who have two games in hand. The surging third-placed New Jersey Devils are now way off on the distant horizon, five points ahead with a game in hand.

We can go as far as to pinpoint the precise moment when perhaps (though hopefully not) the fortunes shifted dramatically in the Rangers season: The start of the third period in Pittsburgh last Wednesday. Going into that period, the Rangers and Penguins were tied 1-1 even though the Blueshirts had clearly been the better team up to that point. After the teams traded goals in the first period and New York was essentially dominating Pittsburgh in the second, I remember thinking ‘this is the type of game the Rangers of seasons past would typically lose. Let’s see what happens here because this could be telling.’ The team was coming off impressive back-to-back home victories and seemed to have momentum in its favor. It was playing tough, defensive hockey and more importantly seemed well-disciplined, staying away from silly mistakes such as turnovers and cheap penalties. I had every reason to believe this season would be different from others the past decade and a half. Or so I thought.

Then that third period happened and the team fell apart, playing perhaps its worst 20 minutes this season. Pittsburgh scored three times in the first 10 minutes and the rout was on. The five goals scored against New York in that period were the most in any period so far this season. And still, the Rangers outshot the Penguins in the game, 34-33. Rangers players were as baffled as anybody. “I just played terrible, I can’t explain it,” said Henrik Lundqvist. Paul Mara also called the experience “unexplainable.”

Tom Renney and the coaching staff deserve credit for getting the team to forget the experience and focus on the next game, at Boston on Saturday afternoon. The Rangers played much better, very well even, but still lost, 1-0, thanks largely to an otherworldly goaltending performance by Bruins rookie Tuukka Rask. “We played the best team in the Eastern Conference right to the letter,” Renney said afterwards. And he was right, of course. But as nice as those type of performances are, they become exercises in frustration if the team doesn’t come away with any points. Unfortunately, these are the types of games mediocre teams (ones that go one and done in the playoffs) lose. They’re also the type of losses that leave fans with the impression these are the same ol’ Rangers after all: good on paper, solid for the most part and sometimes even capable of impressive victories. But ultimately lacking any kind of unified core that can get the team back to the Stanley Cup.

Having said all that, it would obviously be premature (not to mention highly irrational) to write off the Rangers season at this point. There are 30 games left to play (31 to be precise) and the team is well placed for the Eastern Conference playoffs. Plus we have Adam Graves night tomorrow; if that doesn’t get the team fired up, nothing will. It’s not unreasonable to expect the event to propel the team on a more definitive momentum-changing streak–a true “turning point” if you will (with a more positive outcome than what is outlined here). Hopefully, that’s what happens. But these are the Rangers, after all. Until somebody like Mark Messier comes along (and unless he’s flanked by Adam Graves and Brian Leetch), “hope” is something better left abandoned. See you tomorrow night.

Posted under Blog